More, Less, Reinvent, or Fade: My Four Theories of Retirement, Checked Against the Research (and Hayao Miyazaki)

I retired at 62 with four theories about how retirement goes. Then I looked up what the research actually says, and why famous retirees turned out to be the wrong place to look.

I was today days old when I realized that I have retired twice now, and I still have no idea which kind of retiree I am. I tried to retire right before Covid. Then I took a job and worked the last six years. Now, at 62, I am retiring again, and this time I have been sitting around with a theory. Retirement, I figured, goes one of four ways: More, Less, Reinvent, or Fade.

A wooden park bench seen from behind, facing a calm blue lake with a distant tree-lined shoreline under a pale spring sky.
A bench near Rattray Marsh overlooking Lake Ontario. Joe deSousa, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

My definitions:

  • More: retirement magnifies who you already were. If you tinker, you really tinker. If you drink, you may really drink. Good and bad.
  • Less: the volume gets turned down on everything.
  • Reinvent: a new chapter, a new you.
  • Fade: you kinda become frail or die soon.

Then I did what I always do, which is look it up, and found out a psychologist got there first and did it better.

Then I looked it up

A two-story wood-paneled library with carved arches, a balcony, tall shelves of books and reading tables on the floor below.
The reading room of Gladstone’s Library in Hawarden, Wales. Michael D Beckwith, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Nancy Schlossberg interviewed 100 retirees for Retire Smart, Retire Happy (American Psychological Association, 2004) and named five types. By Revitalizing Retirement (2009) the list had grown to six. In her own words, via Money.com and her Psychology Today blog:

  • Continuers modify their activities but keep “continuing along a similar path” (her example: a retired museum director who occasionally curates a show).
  • Adventurers see retirement as “an opportunity to pursue an unrealized dream or try something new.”
  • Easy Gliders see it as “a time to relax” and take each day as it comes.
  • Involved Spectators “still care deeply about their previous work” and follow their old field from the sidelines.
  • Searchers are “looking for their niche” and may move from path to path.
  • Retreaters step back from routines. Some become depressed and inactive; others “use a moratorium to figure out what’s next.”

My loose mapping, which is mine and not hers: More is roughly Continuers, Reinvent is Adventurers, Less is Easy Gliders, and Fade sits near Retreaters, though not neatly, and I will come back to that. She has reportedly said nearly everyone is a Searcher at some point, which I can only pass along second-hand. It also sounds right.

The ones neither of us listed

A white cast railway points lever with a red handle sitting in the grass beside a track, with old rusty rolling stock blurred behind it.
A railway points lever, the device that sends a train onto a different track. Bernard Spragg, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

The gap in my list, and in hers, is the swap: you retire, and then you un-retire. Studio Ghibli’s president announced on September 1, 2013, that The Wind Rises would be Hayao Miyazaki’s last feature. Miyazaki, then 72, confirmed it himself at a Tokyo news conference five days later. Ten years on, The Boy and the Heron opened in Japan on July 14, 2023, with Miyazaki at 82. Producer Toshio Suzuki has said it was made for Miyazaki’s grandson, and his son Goro said in 2021 that his father “needed to create something in order to live.”

It is not just a genius thing. A 2017 King’s College London study found about one in four retired Britons return to work, mostly within five years.

Another missing type is absorbed: retirement not as a goal but as a reassignment. Sandra Day O’Connor announced her retirement from the Supreme Court on July 1, 2005, at 75, and left on January 31, 2006. Her husband John had been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s in 1990, and in 2008 testimony before the Senate Special Committee on Aging she connected her retirement to caring for him, per the ABA Journal’s report on that planned testimony. John died in November 2009. That same year (one source says 2010) she founded iCivics, a civics education program. Reinvented, yes, but by way of being needed somewhere else first.

And then there is finally. Frank McCourt taught in New York City public high schools for decades, retired in the late 1980s, and, reportedly after his 1994 marriage, started writing Angela’s Ashes. It came out in 1996, when he was 66, and won the 1997 Pulitzer Prize for biography or autobiography. He died in 2009 at 78.

Wobble, then settle

Gentle waves roll onto a sandy shore at sunset, with a rocky island on the horizon and dramatic blue and orange clouds overhead.
Sunset over a calm sea in Thailand. paul morris oldskool2016, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

The gerontologist Robert Atchley described retirement as phases: pre-retirement, honeymoon, disenchantment, reorientation, retirement routine, termination. Secondary sources disagree on the exact list, and he never claimed they run in strict order. Poor health and lack of money are the things that predict the disenchantment part.

His continuity theory, published in The Gerontologist in 1989, is the closest thing I found to my More theory: older adults try to keep their existing internal and external structures and prefer strategies rooted in their own past, which he called “a grand adaptive strategy.” Critics say it neglects chronic illness and skews male. And to be clear, no study says “retirement magnifies who you were.” That is my interpretation, with continuity theory as the supporting witness.

Why I’m not naming a celebrity for More, Less, or Fade

I went looking for famous examples of all four and realized I was on the wrong track. Famous people are a terrible sample. They have money, they have staff, and the public only sees what they choose to show. Many of them never really retire. Miyazaki, McCourt, and O’Connor made the cut because the dates are documented. For the other three categories I would just be guessing about strangers. Coaches are the exception, because their retirements are unusually well documented; see below.

Fade is the one I keep circling. The research separates withdrawing by choice (Schlossberg’s Retreaters) from declining health, and in casual conversation those get lumped together. Fade in my sense, the frail-or-gone-soon version, shows up in research rather than headlines:

  • A 2022 meta-analysis in Frontiers in Psychiatry linked involuntary retirement to more depressive symptoms (relative risk 1.31, 95% CI 1.13 to 1.51), while voluntary or age-mandated retirement showed little or no association.
  • Rohwedder and Willis’s 2010 paper “Mental Retirement” found early retirement had a negative effect on cognition in people in their early 60s, across US, English, and European data, with the mechanism still debated.

I am in my early 60s. Noted.

What the science actually says

A white and black student microscope on a wooden desk in a laboratory, with beakers on a bench behind it.
A student microscope in a laboratory. J.Doniyorovich, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Outcomes diverge. Wang (2007, Journal of Applied Psychology), using two Health and Retirement Study samples of 994 and 1,066 people, found three distinct well-being trajectories, and people with bridge jobs held up best.
  • Most people barely move. Pinquart and Schindler (2007, Psychology and Aging) tracked 1,456 German retirees into three groups; the largest showed little change in life satisfaction.
  • How you leave matters more than that you leave (the involuntary-retirement finding above).
  • Volunteering is linked to lower mortality in observational studies, with the usual catch that healthier people may volunteer more.
  • Nobody ranks the types. No source I found says which of Schlossberg’s six is most common.

Coaches: the extremes we remember

Coaches are the one group where retirement is unusually well documented, because everyone is counting. These are the ones I think about. They are stories, not data, and I will get to why that matters. The yellow tag on each is how long they lived after retiring (for Gibbs, how long before he came back). Green tags mark the three who are still alive, as of recent reporting.

  • Bobby Bowden (Florida State): announced his retirement on December 1, 2009, and coached his last game in the Gator Bowl on January 1, 2010, at 80. He was widely reported to have been pressed to step down, and said he had wanted one more season. He died on August 8, 2021, at 91, of pancreatic cancer, about eleven and a half years later. 11 years, 7 months after retiring
  • Joe Paterno (Penn State): the trustees fired him on November 9, 2011, at 84, four days after the arrest of former assistant Jerry Sandusky on child sexual abuse charges. He had announced he would retire at the end of that season. His lung cancer diagnosis was announced November 18, and he died on January 22, 2012, at 85, 74 days after being fired. This is not a clean example: he did not choose to leave, and the scandal and the illness are tangled together. I would not read a cause into it. 2 months after being fired (74 days)
  • Bear Bryant (Alabama): coached his last game, the Liberty Bowl, on December 29, 1982, and died of a heart attack on January 26, 1983, at 69, 28 days later. Asked what he would do in retirement, he reportedly said he would “probably croak in a week.” The wording is secondhand, and at least one local account has him saying something different. less than 1 month after his last game (28 days)
  • John Wooden (UCLA): announced he would retire on March 29, 1975, after the semifinal win over Louisville, then won his tenth national title two days later, at 64. He died on June 4, 2010, at 99, thirty-five years after that. 35 years, 2 months after retiring
  • Don Shula (Miami Dolphins): retired in January 1996 after 33 seasons as an NFL head coach, and died on May 4, 2020, at 90. about 24 years, 4 months after retiring
  • Dean Smith (North Carolina): retired in October 1997 and died on February 7, 2015, at 83. about 17 years, 3 months after retiring
  • Tom Osborne (Nebraska), the reinvention: coached Nebraska through the 1997 season, served in the U.S. House from 2001 to 2007, then became Nebraska’s athletic director in 2007 and announced in September 2012 that he would step down in January 2013. Still alive at 89; in July 2026 he became the first living person inducted into the Nebraska Hall of Fame
  • Joe Gibbs, the swap: resigned as Redskins coach on March 5, 1993, ran Joe Gibbs Racing in NASCAR, and came back to coach the Redskins from 2004 through 2007. He is still an owner of Joe Gibbs Racing, which is in its 35th season in 2026. He is 85 and turns 86 on November 25. came back after about 10 years, 10 months Still alive at 85, and still an owner of Joe Gibbs Racing
  • Bill Parcells, the serial swap: retired from the Giants after Super Bowl XXV in January 1991, came back with the Patriots in 1993, then coached the Jets and the Cowboys, announced his retirement from the Cowboys in January 2007, and then joined the Dolphins front office in 2008. Sources disagree on how many times to count him as retired, so I will not give a number. Still alive at 85; in early 2026 he publicly argued that Bill Belichick and Robert Kraft belong in the Pro Football Hall of Fame

Bowden and Paterno are the pair I think of most: similar job, similar age, very different endings, eleven and a half years versus 74 days. But look at what I just did. I remembered the coaches whose stories ended in a headline, and I did not list the many who retired and quietly played golf for twenty years. That is the problem with anecdotes, and it is why the research above is the real evidence. The coaches are just the human side of it.

So: which one will I be? I honestly don’t know. Ask me in year three.

Sources

« Back to All Stories